2-quinuclidonium tetrafluoroborate

Stoltz and Tani. Nature, 2006,441 (7094) pp 731 DOI: 10.1038/nature04842
Just a quick postlett (I might trade-mark that…) to point out Stoltz’s total synthesis in Nature, as mentioned by “ddd” in the previous post’s comments. This little beasty has been the burden of much discussion and controversy in the community, and the accompanying X-ray is very interesting. Y’see, it’s an anti-Bredt amide, where the nitrogen LP has been forced out of conjugation from the carbonyl, resulting in a radically different amide chemistry (the N behaves much more like an amine).

After a failed synthesis attempt using C–H insertion of rhodium-stabilized acylcarbenesgenerated from diazocarbonyl derivatives, they used an intramolecular Schmidt–Aubé reaction to complete the bicyclic lactam. From a personal standpoint, I find it great that they point out what didn’t work – this is often more useful than a description of what did. Unfortunately, many short articles and letters such as this fail to bother.
Update: Just a few references for those of you who are interested. Tony Kirby has done loads of work in this area, and on related studies, decades prior to this paper.
JOC; 2002; 67, 9288. DOI: 10.1021/jo0206014
JACS; 1998; 120, 7101. DOI: 10.1021/ja980700s
ACIE; 1998; 37, 785. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/…











You have too many carbons in your second amide. In the paper, the minor product has a one carbon bridge, not a two carbon bridge.
Ah, indeed. A beautiful example of the copy/paste error on a Sunday night… Thanks!
Looks like you got Joshua to cite you.
http://blogs.nature.com/thescepticalchymist/2006/06/twisting_the_night_away.html#13401
Mitch
woo hoo
Indeed. Watch my bandwidth quota shrivel-up and die…
Oh, and it’s now been linked via Wikipedia…